Request a planText (512) 809-8236

Retail · Brookhaven, NY

Retail Space for Lease in Brookhaven, NY

Retail in a city this size is a set of distinct districts, from regional malls and lifestyle centers to neighborhood main streets and highway corridors. In Brookhaven, highway-facing retail follows State Route 25 and State Route 112. The ZIP area counted 1,519 retail and 1,058 food-service and lodging establishments in 2023.

Start a search

Request a plan for this market

Tell us about the space you need here. A tenant-side broker will follow up. There is no fee for the tenant.

No cost to the tenant. No obligation.

Retail areas

Where to look for retail space in Brookhaven

8 named areas in and around Brookhaven that we would put on a retail shortlist, with what each suits and what to check.

01

Gateway Plaza

Named retail center about 6.9 miles southwest of the geographic center of Brookhaven. Typical fit: chains, services, and restaurants.

Tenant notePad sites and end caps on a corridor command premium rents, so compare inline space if visibility needs are modest.

Source: OpenStreetMap
02

Centereach Mall

Named retail center about 6.3 miles west of the geographic center of Brookhaven. Typical fit: chains, services, and restaurants.

Tenant notePower centers and strip corridors suit service and chain retailers that rely on visibility from the road.

Source: OpenStreetMap
03

Smith Haven Mall

Shopping center about 8.9 miles west of the geographic center of Brookhaven. Typical fit: national chains and anchors.

Tenant noteEnclosed and open-air centers set different rules on signage and hours, so compare lease terms as well as foot traffic.

Source: OpenStreetMap · Website
04

Sunshine Square

Named retail center about 3.5 miles south of the geographic center of Brookhaven. Typical fit: chains, services, and restaurants.

Tenant noteOn a busy retail corridor, check traffic counts, turn access, and parking, since drivers have to be able to get in easily.

Source: OpenStreetMap
05

Independence Plaza

Named retail center about 4.8 miles west of the geographic center of Brookhaven. Typical fit: chains, services, and restaurants.

Tenant noteOn a busy retail corridor, check traffic counts, turn access, and parking, since drivers have to be able to get in easily.

Source: OpenStreetMap
06

The DSW Plaza at Lake Grove

Named retail center about 8.7 miles west of the geographic center of Brookhaven. Typical fit: chains, services, and restaurants.

Tenant notePower centers and strip corridors suit service and chain retailers that rely on visibility from the road.

Source: OpenStreetMap
07

Nicolls Plaza

Named retail center about 7.5 miles west of the geographic center of Brookhaven. Typical fit: chains, services, and restaurants.

Tenant notePower centers and strip corridors suit service and chain retailers that rely on visibility from the road.

Source: OpenStreetMap
08

College Plaza

Named retail center about 4.7 miles west of the geographic center of Brookhaven. Typical fit: chains, services, and restaurants.

Tenant notePower centers and strip corridors suit service and chain retailers that rely on visibility from the road.

Source: OpenStreetMap

At a glance

Matching Brookhaven areas to tenants

AreaTypical fitFrom center
Gateway PlazaChains, services, and restaurants6.9 mi southwest
Centereach MallChains, services, and restaurants6.3 mi west
Smith Haven MallNational chains and anchors8.9 mi west
Sunshine SquareChains, services, and restaurants3.5 mi south
Independence PlazaChains, services, and restaurants4.8 mi west
The DSW Plaza at Lake GroveChains, services, and restaurants8.7 mi west
Nicolls PlazaChains, services, and restaurants7.5 mi west
College PlazaChains, services, and restaurants4.7 mi west

Business base

Retail-using businesses in Brookhaven

Sector (NAICS)ZIP-area firmsSuffolk County firmsCounty employees
Retail trade1,5196,07977,814
Accommodation & food services1,0584,10355,962
All sectors11,63350,748592,580

ZBP 2023: 11949, 11772, 11961, 11763, 11967, 11980, 11733, 11953 and more. CBP 2023: Suffolk County. n/a = withheld.

Getting there

Access for staff and customers

Interstates
I-495 (through town), I-95 (24 mi)
State routes through town
State Route 25, State Route 112, State Route 27
Toll roads and parkways
Long Island Expressway (2.2 mi), Jericho Turnpike (8.8 mi)
Nearest airline airport
Long Island MacArthur Airport (ISP), Islip · 9 mi
Next airline airport
Tweed New Haven Airport (HVN), New Haven · 28 mi
Principal port district
Port Jefferson, NY · district boundary 8.4 mi · 2.5 million tons in 2023 (No. 106 nationally)
Rail intermodal ramp
Red Hook Container Terminal (CSX, NS), Brooklyn, NY · 56 mi

Straight-line miles from the geographic center of Brookhaven.

Before you sign

What to check on a Brookhaven retail lease

  • VisibilityCheck sightlines from the street, signage rights, and whether the space can be seen from parking.
  • Co-tenancyFind out who the neighbors and anchors are and what happens if an anchor leaves.
  • Use clausesMake sure the lease protects your use and look for exclusives that block competitors.
  • Common area chargesAsk for a history of CAM, tax, and insurance pass-throughs.

Questions

Leasing in Brookhaven: common questions

Where is retail space concentrated in Brookhaven?

The named areas we would look at first are Gateway Plaza, Centereach Mall, Smith Haven Mall, Sunshine Square, Independence Plaza, and The DSW Plaza at Lake Grove. Named retail center about 6.9 miles southwest of the geographic center of Brookhaven.

How many retail-type businesses operate in Brookhaven?

ZIP Code Business Patterns 2023 counts 1,519 retail trade establishments and 1,058 accommodation & food services establishments in the ZIP codes covering Brookhaven.

Get started

Need space in Brookhaven?

Tell us the space type, size, and timing. A tenant-side broker will follow up with a plan for the search, at no cost to you.