Request a planText (512) 809-8236

Commercial space · Suffolk County, New York

Commercial Space for Lease in Middle Island, NY

Middle Island is an unincorporated community, tracked by the Census Bureau as a Census Designated Place, in Suffolk County, New York. The 2020-2024 American Community Survey puts its population at about 11,027. It is part of the New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ metro area, about 57 miles from New York. The nearest interstate, I-495, is about 4.5 miles from the center of Middle Island, and State Route 25 serves the town.

Start a search

Request a plan for this market

Tell us about the space you need here. A tenant-side broker will follow up. There is no fee for the tenant.

No cost to the tenant. No obligation.

At a glance

Middle Island in numbers

Population
11,027 (ACS 2020-2024)
Land area
8.22 sq mi · 1,342 people per sq mi
Type
Unincorporated community (Census Designated Place)
County
Suffolk County
Core-based area
New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ (metro area)
Main ZIP codes
11953

Access

Roads, airports, and freight

Interstates
I-495 (4.5 mi), I-95 (22 mi), I-91 (29 mi)
State routes through town
State Route 25
Toll roads and parkways
Long Island Expressway (4.5 mi), Jericho Turnpike (9.5 mi)
Nearest airline airport
Long Island MacArthur Airport (ISP), Islip · 10 mi
Next airline airport
Tweed New Haven Airport (HVN), New Haven · 26 mi
Principal port district
Port Jefferson, NY · district boundary 7.2 mi · 2.5 million tons in 2023 (No. 106 nationally)
Rail intermodal ramp
Little Ferry, NJ (CSX), North Bergen, NJ · 56 mi

Straight-line miles from the geographic center of Middle Island.

Middle Island by space type

What to expect in a small city like Middle Island

01Office

Office space in Middle Island

Office space in a small city like this tends to split between older downtown buildings and newer suburban-style professional parks near main roads, with medical office as a steady third segment.

Office-type businesses in the ZIP area include 15 professional services firms, 4 finance and insurance offices, 13 real estate firms, and 36 health care establishments, so health care is the largest office-using group here.

02Warehouse & industrial

Warehouse space in Middle Island

A small city typically has light-manufacturing buildings, service and flex space, and some dock-high warehouse space in industrial parks near the main highways.

The interstate (I-495) is a 4.5-mile drive, close enough for regional service fleets but usually too far for large distribution users, who tend to stay next to an interchange. The ZIP-area business count includes 4 manufacturing, 6 wholesale, and 6 transportation and warehousing establishments.

  • Brookhaven Logistics Center
03Retail

Retail space in Middle Island

A small city usually has a downtown or main street, grocery-anchored and strip centers, and a commercial corridor with national chains along the busiest highway.

In Middle Island, highway-facing retail follows State Route 25. The ZIP area counted 30 retail and 18 food-service and lodging establishments in 2023.

Middle Island is unincorporated, so land use and permitting generally sit with Suffolk County rather than a city hall. Check county zoning for the intended use early in the search.

Named areas

Commercial areas in Middle Island

Named shopping centers, business and industrial parks, districts, and anchor campuses mapped in and around Middle Island, each linked to its OpenStreetMap record.

Warehouse & industrial

01

Brookhaven Logistics Center

Industrial or business park about 4.3 miles south of the geographic center of Middle Island, just outside the city limits. Typical fit: light industrial, flex, and distribution.

Source: OpenStreetMap

Business base

Who does business in Middle Island

ZIP code 11953, which covers most of Middle Island, held 254 business establishments in 2023, including 30 in retail trade, 18 in food service and lodging, and 36 in health care.

Across Suffolk County, 50,748 establishments reported 592,580 employees in March 2023. Compared with New York overall, the county has a larger share of construction businesses (15.6% of establishments versus 9.5% statewide) and a smaller share of information (1.2% versus 2.2%).

Sector (NAICS)ZIP-area firmsSuffolk County firmsCounty employees
Retail trade306,07977,814
Accommodation & food services184,10355,962
Health care & social assistance365,226120,902
Professional, scientific & technical155,91840,532
Finance & insurance42,25824,779
Real estate, rental & leasing132,0407,828
Information—5997,562
Transportation & warehousing61,23520,755
Wholesale trade62,77338,877
Manufacturing41,67249,830
Construction487,89249,676
All sectors25450,748592,580

ZBP 2023: 11953. CBP 2023: Suffolk County. n/a = withheld.

Nearby

Cities and towns near Middle Island

Metro guides

Closest WhereNext metro guides

New York overview

Data sources

ACS 2020-24 · Gazetteer 2025 · CBSA 2025 · CBP 2023 · ZBP 2023 · ZCTA-place 2020 · TIGER/Line 2025 · OurAirports · NTAD ports · NTAD rail ramps · OpenStreetMap

Questions

Leasing in Middle Island: common questions

How far is Middle Island, NY from the nearest major metro WhereNext covers?

About 24 miles in a straight line to Bridgeport, CT. The closest interstate to Middle Island is I-495, about 4.5 miles away.

What is the closest airline airport to Middle Island?

Long Island MacArthur Airport (ISP) in Islip, about 10 miles away. Tweed New Haven Airport (HVN) is about 26 miles away.

Which commercial areas in Middle Island are worth a look?

Named areas we would start with include Brookhaven Logistics Center. Each suits a different kind of tenant, so the shortlist depends on your space type.

Get started

Need space in Middle Island?

Tell us the space type, size, and timing. A tenant-side broker will follow up with a plan for the search, at no cost to you.